{"id":8886,"date":"2011-12-07T08:50:22","date_gmt":"2011-12-07T08:50:22","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/www.badreputation.org.uk\/?p=8886"},"modified":"2015-12-04T16:04:33","modified_gmt":"2015-12-04T16:04:33","slug":"christmas-songnerd-santa-baby","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/badreputation.org.uk\/2011\/12\/07\/christmas-songnerd-santa-baby\/","title":{"rendered":"Christmas Songnerd: Santa Baby"},"content":{"rendered":"
It’s December.<\/p>\n
I have no idea how that happened so fast, but either way you can’t now
enter the local shopping centre without being bombarded by
Now That’s What I Call The Best Xmas… Ever! (Vol.64)<\/strong>.
In honour of the season, I thought, time allowing, that I’d do some
little case studies on some of the songs currently assaulting your ears as
you shop. You may hate all Christmas music, or you may love it –
personally I’ve never minded it much – but pop singles are like
miniature time capsules, so examining their gender politics, and what
happens to these when new artists cover them, is one way to divert your
brain into a state of broad feminist contemplation rather than all-out
anti-consumerist rage in the queue at HMV1<\/a><\/sup>.<\/p>\n
Um. I
said<\/em> contemplation. But I can’t guarantee that every vid
embedded in this series I’m proposing won’t have you
reaching for a pretty stiff drink.<\/p>\n
Anyway! Cast your mind, readers, back to the postwar baby boom
– specifically 1953. Elizabeth II ascends the throne here in
the UK! Everest is climbed and DNA discovered! And the volume of
the Kinsey Reports titled Sexual Behaviour in the Human Female<\/strong><\/a>, an attempt
to research women’s sexual appetites and desires, is
published to great controversy and brouhaha. And in December,
this guy called Hugh Hefner launches some magazine or other and
sells over 54,000 copies. The cultural melting pot for the
sexual revolution of the Sixties is neatly bubbling away.<\/p>\n
Christmas novelty smash hits have become a Thing since the War
– White Christmas<\/strong><\/a> came out in 1942. And into
this arena slinks
Santa Baby<\/strong>, recorded by Eartha Kitt<\/strong><\/a> and penned by Joan Javits (a
Republican Senator’s niece). It sashays onto the
airwaves with a
ba-boom-ba-boom<\/em> of barbershoppy backing vocals,
tongue shoved firmly in its cheek.<\/p>\n
These days it’s been heard so often and
covered enough times that people seem to have
forgotten that it’s witty, that it actually
stands out as distinct from more earnest fare like
White Christmas<\/strong>.
White Christmas<\/strong> is about a generation
of people longing for their loved ones during
the War. It dreams of idyllic peacetime
Christmases.
Santa Baby<\/strong>, on the other hand, is a
playful and sly kick in the tender area for
rising peacetime consumerism, as well as a
tale of a trophy wife who always wants more
stuff, from yachts to platinum mines to rings
(not on the phone). In 1954 Eartha re-recorded
a version called
This Year’s Santa Baby<\/strong>, the
lyrics<\/a> of which
reveal that the yacht wasn’t all it
was cracked up to be and our heroine
still<\/em> isn’t satisfied.<\/p>\n
For the feminists in the queue at HMV,
especially those being subjected to
the Pussycat
Dolls version<\/a>, this is naturally
not unproblematic, not least because
the kind of woman the song portrays
appears to be exactly what Catherine
Hakim, in her book Honey Money<\/strong><\/a>, wants
women to aspire to be like.
Without<\/em> any tongue in cheek
about it. And
Honey Money<\/strong> only came
out this year, despite the fact
that it appears to be the
product of what happens when you
take Eartha Kitt
completely literally<\/em>.
The gold digger the song
portrays is a popular
stereotype, and the
song’s contemporary with
the postwar rise in popularity
of the “male
breadwinner” family
model, which wasn’t
economically feasible across
all social classes. More
generally, of course,
it’s a riff on a whole
social trope around
women’s bodies and
feminine sexual allure as a
source of transactional
power.<\/p>\n
I think for a lot of people,
being exposed to the
versions Kylie<\/a>,
the ‘Dolls et al have
come out with has somehow
managed to dampen our sense
of the irony within the
original – which makes
more sense within the
context of more
‘wholesome’
Fifties Christmas music,
which it does snerk at, and
class politics of the time
– perhaps because
newer versions are
contemporary with many songs
that
aren’t<\/em>
particularly ironic in
their appreciation of
Worldly Stuff?<\/p>\n
Shame, really, because
Eartha had this sending
up the golddigger
stereotype thing pretty
down. Check out her
recording of Old Fashioned
Millionaire<\/strong><\/a>,
which is similar to
Santa
Baby<\/strong> but
ever so slightly
more acerbic, ably
sending up cliches
of postwar
consumerism,
patronising
Empire-era
South
Pacific<\/strong>-style
racism (which as a
mixed race
performer she was
certainly no
stranger to) and
middle class
pretensions around
social properness
and upward
mobility with
lines like
“I want
an old fashioned
house with an
old fashioned
fence \/ and an
old fashioned
millionaire”<\/em>
and
“I like
Chopin and
Bizet \/ and
the songs of
yesterday \/
String
quartets and
Polynesian
carols \/ But
the music that
excels \/ is
the sound of
oil wells \/
as they
slurp-slurp-slurp
into the
barrels…”
<\/em><\/p>\n
There are
a lot of
other
covers of
the song
out there,
like the
bratty
pop-punk
stylings
of the Dollyrots<\/strong><\/a>
–
Wikipedia
lists
loads<\/a>.
Most
notable
for me,
in very
different
ways,
are
these
two.<\/p>\n
RuPaul’s
1997
cover
takes
precisely
no
prisoners,
announcing
“Been
an
awful
good
queen”,
and
adding
in
caustic
asides
like
“Now
honey,
Miss
RuPaul
has
been
so
good,
it
just
hurts,
and
now I
want
you to
reciprocate<\/em>…
by
givin’
me a
few
ITEMS<\/em>,
you
know…”
and
the
wink-nudge
reply
to
“come
and
trim
my
Christmas
tree…”
of
“Honey,
you
ain’t
trimmin’
nothin’<\/em>.”<\/p>\n
Surely
after
that
glorious
effort
there
was
nowhere
else
the
song
could
really
go,
right?<\/p>\n
Wrong!<\/p>\n
From
the
sublime,
dear
readers,
to
the
ever
so
slightly
ridiculous.<\/p>\n
For
lo,
Santa
Baby<\/strong>
has
just
this
year
been
covered
again
by
–
wait
for
it
–
Michael
Bubl\u00e9<\/strong>,
god-emperor
of
bland,
whose
official
site
bio
at
the
time
of
writing
boasted
frankly
awesomely
reality-disconnected
statements
like
“his
essence
remains
solid
as
a
rock”,
and
“like
Elvis”.
But
let’s
not
stare
into
that
particular
abyss
too
long
–
back
to
Santa
Baby<\/strong>,
for
which
Bubl\u00e9’s
version
has
completely
rewritten
the
lyrics
to
recast
the
entire
song
as
being
about…
um…
a
straight
dude
who
likes
presents.<\/p>\n
That’s
it.<\/p>\n
No
erotic
funny
business
round
here;
Michael’s
after
CARS
and
FOOTBALL
TICKETS
and
he’s
going
to
MAKE
PLATONIC
MANLY
BRO-FRIENDS
with
Santa
until
he
gets
them.
Clearing
all
that
flirting
out
the
way
–
presumably
to
make
room
for
all
the
“decorations
bought
from
…
Mercedes”,
because
I
have
NO
idea
how
you
hang
a
car
bonnet
on
a
Christmas
tree,
after
all
–
he
cracks
out
“Santa,
buddy<\/em>”
at
one
point,
and
makes
sure
to
stipulate
that
the
convertible
needs
to
be
“steel
blue”,
since
presumably
“light
blue”
wasn’t
quite
macho
enough.
Though
I’m
not
sure
it
really
works,
it’s
fascinating
–
and
the
complete
opposite
of
what
RuPaul
does
with
it.
He
even
throws
in
a
fastidiously
heteromanly
“I’ll
wait
up
for
you,
dude<\/em>“,
to
avoid
looking
too
camp.<\/p>\n
Of
course,
in
this,
as
with
nearly
everything
else
Michael
Bubl\u00e9
attempts
to
accomplish
that
isn’t
looking
like
every
photo
of
him
would
be
marvellously
improved
by
the
addition
of
hungry
velociraptors<\/a>,
he
fails
hilariously.<\/p>\n
Mind
you,
to
be
fair
to
Michael,
for
every
alteration
he
makes
to
keep
the
conversation
with
Santa
strictly
platonic
–
“Santa
pally”
(?!)
–
he
also
adds
in
“been
a
sweetie
all
year”
rather
than
Eartha
Kitt’s
original
“been
an
angel”,
and
where
Eartha
has
“think
of
all
the
fellas
that
I
haven’t
kissed”,
Michael’s
got
“hotties”,
which
is
pretty
gender
neutral,
the
writers
clearly
being
aware
that
in
the
marketing
niche
he
belongs
in,
squarely
between
Ronan
Keating
and
Will
Young,
for
every
five
straight
middle
aged
women
buying
his
records,
there’s
also
a
pretty
significant
gay
following
–
he
mentioned
it
himself
with
some
enthusiasm
in
an
interview<\/a>.<\/p>\n
And
really,
for
all
the
“women
like
jewellery
and
men
like…
CARS”
binary
implications
in
there…
there’s
something
about
the
way
he
goes
“forgot
to
mention
one
little
thing
\/
cha-ching!”
that
just
isn’t
really
all
that
macho
after
all.
It’s
almost
rather
sweet.
Or
maybe
I’ve
been
looking
at
all
those
images
of
him
being
stalked
by
raptors
just
a
bit
too
much
and
started
feeling
sorry
for
him.<\/p>\n
It
only
seems
right
to
end
such
a
string
of
different
treatments
of
a
song
about
femininity
and
consumerism
with
the
ultimate
scion
of
both:
Miss
Piggy<\/strong>.
I
truly
believe
that
she
is
perhaps
the
only
one
who’s
almost
on
a
par
with
Eartha
herself.
Think
of
all
the
froggies
she
hasn’t<\/em>
kissed!<\/p>\n
Been an Awful Good Girl<\/h3>\n
Come And Trim My Christmas Tree \/ With
Erotic Capital From Tiffany<\/h3>\n
Some Very
Different
Covers<\/h3>\n
Santa
Buddy<\/h3>\n