{"id":10238,"date":"2012-03-13T09:00:01","date_gmt":"2012-03-13T09:00:01","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/www.badreputation.org.uk\/?p=10238"},"modified":"2012-03-13T09:00:01","modified_gmt":"2012-03-13T09:00:01","slug":"gamer-diary-assassins-creed-3-reactions-roundtable","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/badreputation.org.uk\/2012\/03\/13\/gamer-diary-assassins-creed-3-reactions-roundtable\/","title":{"rendered":"[Gamer Diary] – Assassin’s Creed 3: Reactions Roundtable"},"content":{"rendered":"
Three short months after the release of Ezio\u2019s last dance,
Assassin\u2019s Creed: Revelations<\/strong>, and we’ve been graced
by the presence of the first
Assassin\u2019s Creed III<\/strong> reveal.\u00a0 So Stephen B, Markgraf,
Miranda and I had a chatette.<\/p>\n
First off: go check out
the trailer if you haven\u2019t seen it already.<\/a><\/p>\n
Stephen B:<\/strong> Well, I’m a Brit, and that probably
colours my reaction to the setting. I’m just not invested in how
glorious the War of Independence was, and killing the dastardly
English isn’t really as exciting to me as Assassins vs.
Templars.<\/p>\n
My first reaction was concern for the fighting: is going up against
guns with a small hand-axe really going to work? \u00a0The moves
lacked the skill and finesse of previous styles, although
they’re better on a repeat viewing.\u00a0 Plus, I am a bit
disappointed that no-one else is following
Mass Effect 3<\/strong>‘s lead<\/a> and doing female
version trailers. Or… having
even one female<\/em> in the whole trailer.<\/p>\n
All this grand posturing is about English vs. American white
guys only and the protagonist is of Native American descent,
so while you’re blowing all those trumpets you’re
ignoring the incredible ongoing & future genocide. The
game
might<\/em> highlight how his people are treated as part of
the story, but that’s not clear from the
trailer.<\/p>\n
Miranda:<\/strong> Would it be possible to have a
leading lady in this franchise? I’d love that
– I like the Orlando<\/strong><\/a>-esque idea of the protagonist
being different genders through time – but
isn’t Desmond<\/a>
always the person, er, “wearing” the
history? So I imagine we’d have to lose him as
well; they’d have to create a female equivalent?
Even without that leap, I’m personally hoping
there are less Sex Assassin type ladies this time
around, and more, y’know, female
characters<\/em>.<\/p>\n
Readers might remember the last
time we covered Assassin’s Creed on here and
talked about the Sex Assassin NPC thing<\/a>
– Ubisoft Workshop staff actually read the
post, which featured Markgraf’s own designs
for female assassins, and gave it a friendly
shoutout, which was nice to see (sadly, when I try
to find the
shoutout<\/a>, it’s been archived and
doesn’t seem to have the hyperlinks anymore.
Shame, that – we were originally hyperlinked
from “we thought this would quell some
people’s fears on where we stand on
important subjects”). We then had a bit of
feedback from people who pointed out that there
are female assassins in
ACII<\/strong> you can deploy places, so then
we made another
post to address that a bit<\/a>, because the
point is, we’re aware of that, but
it’s not like there isn’t room for a
good deal of progress. <\/p>\n
Rai:<\/strong> I too am concerned about how
they\u2019ll fit this protagonist into the
grand scheme of things: after all
historically it’s one set of
oppressive zealots complaining about being
oppressed (by the English) without a shadow
of irony as they murder and destroy the
indigenous population.\u00a0 Given the
protagonist’s ethnicity, one has to
wonder how he’s on either side of this
war, given the racist sentiments aimed at
Native Americans (in that era and
beyond).<\/p>\n
On the anti-Brit theme, I have my doubts
that it’ll be handled appropriately
or even accurately – there are
tendencies when anything American is
involved for Brits to be portrayed as some
sort of devil spawn (which is getting
pretty dull).<\/p>\n
I’m pretty peeved it is
still <\/em><\/strong>a dude.\u00a0
What happened to all the stuff at the
end of
Brotherhood<\/strong> when Minerva
was telling Desmond to go and find
this ‘other assassin’
he’d need to beat the
Templars?\u00a0 Minerva was using
female pronouns to talk about this
other assassin – so, where is
she?<\/p>\n
Changing tack slightly: the
trees(!) – in the trailer we
see the guy free-running among the
branches. This could be an
interesting switch from the
buildings we’re used to thus
far.<\/p>\n
Also did anyone else hear the
theory that
AC3<\/strong> would be set in
the Far East?\u00a0 If so…
would Far East have been a
better setting than 1777
America?\u00a0 I think so, but
then America is of very little
interest to me as it all feels
quite egomaniacal: could the
setting of
AC3<\/strong> be a ploy to
get more US fans?\u00a0 Or to
bring the centre of attention
back on to the USA, as is the
tendency of
so many<\/em> games?<\/p>\n
Stephen B:<\/strong>
Well, I suppose the
previous games were
quite brave in that the
first one had you
playing a medieval Arab,
and the second went to
Italy with no mention of
the US. So it could be
okay that they do
one<\/em> in the
USA… but the Far
East would have been a
lot more exciting for
me.<\/p>\n
Markgraf:<\/strong>
As per Rai’s
reaction,
I’m baffled
as to why our hero
isn’t a
woman, still
– I mean,
come on,
it’s 2012,
surely we know
that women exist
by now and that
it’s fine to
have them as
protagonists?<\/p>\n
But my angle is
this one:
I’m keen
to see people of
colour
represented as
actual hero-y
heroes in games,
because
it’s damn
rare, it’s
still<\/em>
damn rare, and
that’s
frankly an
embarrassment
to
civilisation
as a
whole.\u00a0
So I’m
delighted,
actually, to
see that
Ratohnhak\u00e9:ton
is mixed race
and doing his
bit for First
Nations people
in
games.<\/p>\n
The
Assassin’s
Creed<\/strong>
franchise
is doing
itself
quite
proud of
multiculturalism
in
games:\u00a0it
started
the series
with you
playing
Altaiir
ibn
La-Ahad,
who is a
Syrian
Arab, born
and
raised,
which is
literally
one of the
only
examples I
can think
of where
the
playable
protagonist
is
Arab.\u00a0
But
you’ll
all
remember
that
Altaiir
had an
American
voice, and
if you
peered
under his
hood, it
was
Desmond
doing an
Altaiir
cosplay.\u00a0
So, you
had a
character
with the
right sort
of name
for the
place he
was in,
but
without
the right
sort of
voice, and
not really
the right
sort of
face,
either,
which was
pretty
much
ethnicity-trimming,
if you ask
me.<\/p>\n
No-one
can
possibly
have any
problems
with the
representation
of First
Nations
people
–
they’re
under-represented
and
it’s
uncontroversial
to
represent
them as
heroes
–
and
that’s
great<\/em>,
but I
do
feel
bad
for
Altaiir,
the
Arab
hero
that
never
really
was.<\/p>\n
I’m
not
that
thrilled
by
the
setting,
either,
to
be
honest.\u00a0
For
all
the
reasons
we’ve
mentioned
(yet
another
America-centric
game)
but
also
because…
I
just
want
to
see
a
more
diverse
range
of
ethnic
backgrounds
to
playable
characters,
really.\u00a0
So
couldn’t
we
have
wandered
further
afield
than
America
for
the
third?<\/p>\n
(And
raise
your
hand
if
you’re
bored
of
having
The
English!!!
as
villains
in
things…)<\/p>\n
Oh,
and
I’m
also
excited
that
YOU
CAN
CLIMB
TREES!!!!,
yes.<\/p>\n
Rai:<\/strong>
I
too
am
more
than
pleased
that
the
AC<\/strong>
franchise
has
done
good
things
for
protagonists
of
diverse
ethnicity
and
to
have
another
character
in
that
trend
is
good;
even
better
if
he
is
actually
his
own
self
and
not
just
Desmond-in-a-hood!\u00a0
Their
failings
with
portraying
Altaiir
appropriately
will
always
stick
in
my
mind
though.<\/p>\n
It
is
a
shame
it’s
not
a
woman
though,
and
it
is
a
shame
it’s
in
America
–
if
previous
form
is
anything
to
go
by,
we
may
end
up
with
a
trilogy
of
games
in
that
period,
and
I
suspect
they’ve
brought
it
home
to
America
so
they
can
more
easily
blend
into
Desmond
fighting
Templars
himself
in
the
present\/future.\u00a0
So
I
have
no
idea
where
on
earth
this
‘she’
assassin
Minerva
was
banging
on
about
is
going
to
come
from.\u00a0
I
truly
hope
they
don’t
just
let
Desmond
find
her
and
then
she’s
an
unplayable
sidekick
character.<\/p>\n
Miranda:<\/strong>
\u201cHurrah
for
more
beautiful
vertigo-inducing
rendering,
but
let’s
hope
there
are
some
women
NPCs
at
least
in
this
that
are
written
as
characters,
not
damsels
and
sex
machines!\u201d<\/p>\n
Stephen
B:<\/strong>
\u201cPotential
racial
sensitivity
GOOD,
provided
they
stick
to
it.
Setting’s
a
bit
blah;
hoping
the
general
‘Assassins
vs
Templars’
struggle
is
enough
of
a
hook
to
keep
me
interested.\u201d<\/p>\n
Markgraf:<\/strong>
\u201cI
BET
THE
FANDOM
ARE
MORE
HAPPY
TO
ACCURATELY
REPRESENT
THIS
GUY’S
ETHNICITY
THAN
ALTAIIR’S
BECAUSE
HE
WON’T
BE
ALL
WHITEWASHED
IN-GAME
LOL\u201d<\/p>\n
Rai:<\/strong>
\u201cWhere
is
my
she-assassin?!\u00a0
Good
to
see
an
appropriately
portrayed
non-white
protagonist,
but
the
American
setting
feels
like
a
bit
of
a
disappointment,
and
definitely
poked
my
inner
cynic
with
a
very
pointy
stick.\u201d<\/p>\n
Conclusions:<\/h3>\n